Paper: Ideology, Psychology, and Law (Hanson)

Formally, the law is based solely on reasoned analysis, devoid of ideological biases or unconscious influences. Judges claim to act as umpires applying the rules, not making them. They frame their decisions as straightforward applications of an established set of legal doctrines, principles, and mandates to a given set of facts. As most legal scholars understand, however, the impression that the legal system projects is largely an illusion. As far back as 1881, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. made a similar claim, writing that “the felt necessities of the time, the prevalent moral and political theories, intuitions of public policy, avowed or unconscious, even the prejudices which judges share with their fellow-men, have a good deal more to do than the syllogism in determining the rules by which men should be governed.”

More than a century later, we are now much closer to understanding the mechanisms responsible for the gap between the formal face of the law and the actual forces shaping it. Over the last decade or so, political scientists and legal academics have begun studying the linkages between ideologies, on one hand, and legal principles and policy outcomes on the other. During that same period, mind scientists have turned to understanding the psychological sources of ideology. This book is the first to bring many of the world’s experts on those topics together to examine the sometimes unsettling interactions between psychology, ideology, and law, and to better understand what, beyond and beneath the logic, animates the law.

This introductory chapter describes why this volume came together when it did and provides an overview of the general sections and the individual chapters and comments in the book. It begins with a brief, loose, and highly stylized history of the relationships between ideology, psychology, and law — a history premised on the oversimplifying assertion that something changed around the year 2000.

Keywords: Ideology, Psychology, Law, Legal Theory, Social Psychology, Mind Sciences, Social Cognition

Place #3 in TOP 10 Papers for Journal of CSN: Law (Topic)
February 8, 2012 to April 8, 2012

Suggested Citation: Hanson, Jon D., Ideology, Psychology, and Law (January 1, 2012). Ideology, Psychology and Law, 2012. Available at SSRN:

This post will expire at 4:24pm on Thursday September 25th, 2014

Comments are closed.